Poland Post

March-April 2019

Wow...there’s a lot to cover here. Since this is undoubtedly going to be a long blog entry, I’ve divided it into multiple parts. I’m sorry for the lack of punctuality on my part in writing this entry and I hope everyone understands the historical and cultural significance of the Shoah. This is a sensitive subject.

Opening Thoughts

Learning about something factually drains the significance from it. My teachers in elementary and middle school didn’t feel comfortable discussing the Holocaust from any other point of view, so I was stuck with a bunch of statistics and facts that didn’t really convey the true horror of what happened. Sure, I can hear the number six million, and think to myself that that’s a huge number, but without learning about the individual journey each and every Jew went through, how will I experience the Shoah from anything other than a complete outsider’s point of view? On the day I’m writing this, actually, my group heard an account from a survivor, Rena Quint, and I was in awe at what she had to face.

I cleared my expectations for Poland, hoping not to form any misconceptions that could hurt my experience, so there isn’t much to write about there, but what I can say is that every Jewish person, young or old, religious or secular, associated or unassociated with the state of Israel, should be obligated to visit Poland and view these sites firsthand.

Itinerary and Thoughts on Individual Days:

The following account is a formatted version of notes that I hastily typed on my phone whenever I had a spare minute or two. I am very aware of the grammatical and spelling errors but have chosen to keep the notes for posterity.

Below each account, I will provide additional thoughts that I have as a write this entry.

Day 1 - Tykocin

Later thoughts: The first day was pretty hard for me and other students emotionally. Bear in mind that we had just got off a red-eye flight and were being pushed to the limit both physically and emotionally, and we thought we were in for a relaxed day of touring a Polish village. When taken to the forest where we witnessed the result of mass killings, we were all shocked and unprepared. Part of me wishes that the program didn’t start off like this - I, personally, wasn’t emotionally prepared to process how an entire community could be forced to dig their own grave. While I had heard of horror stories like these in the past, seeing it firsthand made it eerily real.

Note that I’m writing a blog entry as an assignment for Day #1 in Tykocin. When I write it, I’ll attach a link here.

Day 2 - Jewish Cemetery + Warsaw Ghetto

Later thoughts: I didn’t write many notes for this day, but I think that this was one of the most important days on the trip. The cemetery and memorial walk (iberleben) were both significant, but not noticeably rememberable. Learning about the Warsaw Ghetto and finally seeing a strip of it really hurt me, but what hurt me more was the fact that the remaining strip of wall was in the middle of an apartment complex - and a senior citizen actually yelled at us for talking too loudly when we were near the wall. While this may not be a universal theme, I felt it showed that in only 80 years, people were already disregarding the significance of the Holocaust and were angry at the constant disruptions that Holocaust remembrance brought. Obviously we aren’t going to forget the Holocaust, but are we considering it less significant than we did initially? I know I can’t base my analysis on a single person, but what happened really bothered me and my entire class.

Day 3 - Yeshiva and Majdanek Extermination Camp

Later thoughts: This was probably the hardest day of the trip for me and many of my friends. The smaller size of Majdanek made it more digestible for me and the other students. This was our first real exposure to the Final Solution - when the Nazis agreed on a streamlined process for mass murder. It was incomprehensible to see barbed wire that I knew hadn’t been used to keep people out, but instead keep people in. Receiving a note from my parents right after visiting Majdanek made the day much more tolerable.

Day 4 - Relaxed

Later thoughts: I’m glad we were given a more relaxed day after Majdanek. While we still learned about Jewish life in Poland, we didn’t have to see any disturbing or saddening sights. Plus, the town square was truly unique - I love old architecture and seeing some of the designs for ancient churches and clock towers was really fascinating. Plus, we had some delicious food and time for souvenir shopping.

Day 5 - Auschwitz

Later thoughts: Auschwitz was so large in size that it was hard for many of us to take in all that we saw. To this day, I believe I am still processing all we saw there. We first visited Auschwitz-Birkenau, the section dedicated to housing and gassing, and then later Auschwitz I, which has become very museumified. While all other days on this program focused on at least one aspect regarding life before the Holocaust, Day 5 was absolutely focused on death and mass murder - there were no half hearted efforts to cheer us up, this was a time when everyone accepted that they felt extremely sad and embraced their emotions. I think it’s amazing how we were all so close to each other that we could depend on one another for someone to talk to or simply a hug. This was definitely the most sobering day of the whole program - even disruptive students didn’t make a single interruption when seeing firsthand what happened.

Day 6 - Bus Ride

Later thoughts: More of a relaxed day. Interesting and inspiring to hear stories of iberleben from DSol, who is an amazing speaker and storyteller.

Day 7 - Polish History Museum

Later thoughts: Not as important of a day. The museum was very repetitive in nature to content already covered and wasn’t very interesting. Leaving Poland left me with conflicting emotions.

Conclusion

Please look at my Poland Essay for an illustration of my final thoughts regarding Poland and what I witnessed. There's also more I would love to add to this post when I get time...I'm so pressed for time these days but I had to get a draft out.